Michael Jordan never became a great coach. Neither did Tom Brady. Across sports, the people on the sideline are rarely the ones who were best on the field, and the same pattern plays out every time a company hands its top performer a team.
Season 3 of Raw Talent opens with the question the whole season will work through: why does promoting a team’s top performer so often backfire? Jackson Sprayberry puts it to Anderson Williams, who answers with a line a portfolio sales leader once gave him: the only thing sales and sales manager have in common is the word sales. The mindset that makes someone a hunter is, in almost every way, the opposite of what it takes to get work done through other people.
The conversation covers why growing companies so often promote into roles that do not exist yet, what to look for beyond the KPIs when two people post the same numbers, the first-month trap that wears new managers out, and the honest conversation a company owes someone before the promotion. The through line is simple: promoting your best performer makes logical sense until it doesn’t, and the companies that keep their best people are the ones who go in eyes wide open.
If two people on your team have identical numbers, which one would you promote, and why?
In this episode:
- 00:00 – Introduction
- 01:49 – Promoting Into a Role That Doesn’t Exist Yet
- 03:17 – Same KPIs, Different Promotion
- 04:28 – Getting the Work Done Through People
- 06:23 – New Managers Don’t Stop Doing Their Old Job
- 07:34 – Signals Someone Is Ready to Lead
- 09:15 – What You Owe Someone Before You Promote Them
Introduction
Jackson Sprayberry: All right. Let’s get started with the first episode. Sounds good. So the core question that we’re gonna focus on today is why does promoting a team’s top performer so often backfire?
Anderson Williams: Hmm. Yeah, it’s a– You start with a big one. Um What we see most often is when you promote a top performer, uh, they’re a top performer a- at the job they’re doing today.
And just like an example of a Michael Jordan or a Tom Brady, people who are the peak of the peak, they’re not great coaches. They don’t become coaches. You look across sports, and the coaches aren’t typically the ones who were the best on the field. I think it’s the same metaphor. Sure, of course, we like sports metaphors, so I’ll start there.
But I think it’s a different job. Uh, and, uh, we don’t recognize the degree to which it is fundamentally a different job. I had a, a, a portfolio, uh, CEO and one of his sort of mentees that he had brought up through, uh, sales, uh, in the organization tell me one time the only thing that sales and sales manager have in common is the word sales.
Um, because the mindset that it takes to go out and be a hunter and be an individual performer to drive sales is actually in almost direct opposition in every way to what you have to do to manage people. So I think it’s– that’s an extreme example, but it’s that pattern that plays out in varying degrees in, in, in a lot of situations.
Promoting Into a Role That Doesn’t Exist Yet
Jackson Sprayberry: Well, that makes sense to me, but walk me through. It seems almost like a paradox because the phrase that we often hear is we promote people to the position they’re already performing at or the level they’re already performing at. So we’re promoting on capability at a current level and then just hoping for leadership on the back end.
It, it seems in conflict.
Anderson Williams: Yeah, I think it– especially in growing companies and in microcap companies, we’re often promoting to a position that doesn’t exist or hasn’t been well codified, so we don’t have the example of what good looks like for a manager or for a multi-site manager or… And so what do we do?
Of course, we go to the people who are the– seem to be the best team players, who, who perform well, who know the business. It makes logical sense kind of until it doesn’t. Uh, but that becomes a structural challenge and, and an awareness challenge that we are, we are promoting someone into a role that we don’t necessarily understand yet, they don’t understand yet, and we’re promoting them based on criteria that often doesn’t match the end game of, of the role they’re going into.
Jackson Sprayberry: That makes sense. So it’s almost like this– there’s a natural instinct to rely on someone’s current performance because there isn’t a blueprint. And, and, and what else do you
Anderson Williams: have? I mean, your– the data you have is how they’re performing currently.
Jackson Sprayberry: So what, what does how they’re performing currently signal or tell you about their readiness to be a manager?
Same KPIs, Different Promotion
Anderson Williams: I think it– I think you have to look at performance. When you’re thinking about promotion, you have to look at performance beyond the KPIs for the given role So you and I could both be excelling in a given role, um, but I could be someone who knocks that out, doesn’t engage much in team meetings, doesn’t cause a problem, but isn’t really interested in stepping up and helping or staying late when someone else is behind, or doing these other things that have to do with people connections.
Our KPIs could look exactly the same. But if I observe you talking with other people, asking questions to other people, helping other people think through their challenges, uh, stepping up and supporting them, staying late, uh, being a part of the team during team meetings and engaging and asking thought-provoking questions and things like that, you’re the better promotion whether my KPIs are better or equal because of those things that aren’t showing up for your current role.
They weren’t necessarily a part of the job description in your current role, but they’re the stuff that you have to look for if you’re gonna move someone into a people leadership role.
Jackson Sprayberry: So then what, what are the real aspects or what is the real job of a manager, and how is it different, Dan?
Getting the Work Done Through People
Anderson Williams: I think, well, yeah, what, what we see in most cases is, is a situation where our, our promotion is from individual contributor to manager.
So there, there’s manager to more manager, but in the individual contributor to manager, as an individual contributor, your job is to execute the work at the highest degree. Um, and, and doing that is what gets you rewarded. It’s what gets you recognized. It’s what gives you pride in your work. It’s all of those things that are really good and important.
A manager has to get that work done through people, not themselves. They have to figure out, how do I motivate? How do I engage? How do I coach? How do I, uh, uh, ask questions? How– What do I do with Jackson to get Jackson to execute at the level of outstanding individual contributor that maybe I used to be at?
Well, that’s a totally different mindset. I mean, it’s, it’s, it’s again, like the sales and sales manager. It is, it is totally different. Some people can make that transition. It’s not to say they’re mutually exclusive, but it’s the why– it’s why the individual contributor doesn’t always naturally shift into a management role.
Jackson Sprayberry: You know, hearing you talk about that, it reminds me of the seven seismic shifts that we often talk about, and the one example that’s coming to mind is the difference between a builder and an architect.
Anderson Williams: Yeah.
Jackson Sprayberry: I know it’s a slightly different context, but, um, there are these moves that you have to make where you’re not the doer.
Anderson Williams: Yeah.
Jackson Sprayberry: You’re the one that architects the things that other
Anderson Williams: people are doing. And which means you have to understand not just what needs to get done. You have to understand how they think, how they think about the problem. Why do they think that way about the problem? How do they prioritize? How do they handle stress?
How do they– All of those things that are working through the human, not just working through the process that’s required to get the work done.
New Managers Don’t Stop Doing Their Old Job
Jackson Sprayberry: So what do you think the, the biggest surprise to a new manager in the first month is?
Anderson Williams: Uh, they don’t know how to stop doing their old job. Um, almost every new manager I talk to, even if they’ve done a little bit of it, is still carrying that individual contributor load.
And in some cases, they’re still carrying all of the individual, uh, contributor load and now managing a team, uh, which is wearing them out. They’re not as happy in their job. They’re not performing as well in their job. Their team’s looking around wondering, “Well, what are we supposed to do if you do all of that?”
So I think that, that, that acc– they, they end up accumulating work, not shifting their work, uh, in that, in that early phase of becoming a manager.
Jackson Sprayberry: You know, in episode two, we are going to discuss, um, what does a new manager stop doing, uh, as they take on the new work, and so I’m excited to jump into that.
Before we go there, you started to touch on it a moment ago, but what are the three to five key indicators that someone should be looking for in someone they’re looking to promote to a management role?
Signals Someone Is Ready to Lead
Anderson Williams: Yeah. I, I mean, I think it’s, it’s those interactions that they’re having with other members of the team.
Yes, they have to know how to do the work. So I don’t wanna make this sound like an individual contributor is only an individual contributor. That’s, that’s, that’s crazy. They have to understand the work, and they have to know the work. If I am, uh, a subject matter expert on your team- And you see me explaining the work to somebody else, that’s a good sign.
Rather than isolating and executing and being just about my individual performance. If you hear me ask questions in meetings that are forward-looking, not just about today’s execution, but seeing around the corner for what happens when we add this technology, or what happens when AI does this, or what happens when we add this new team member.
If you see me thinking beyond today’s execution, that’s a great sign. Um, if I’m asking questions, uh, in a productive manner to understand work and context beyond my given role. If I’m asking questions about, uh, how and why we’re growing, if I’m asking questions on the direction of the company, if I’m engaged in those bigger cur- that I’m not isolating to I’m doing my job.
If you see that kind of thinking, that kind of engagement, it’s a good sign. It’s not like it’s a guarantee, but it’s a good sign that somebody is thinking about the bigger context and not just the delivery of their role, and, and those are things I would keep an eye out. And I, I, I mean, this, this may seem obvious, but before you promote somebody, make sure they understand what the new role is and that they actually want it.
What You Owe Someone Before You Promote Them
Jackson Sprayberry: That’s actually what I was gonna ask next is, so maybe I have identified somebody that I want to promote into a management role. What does the company– what do I owe that person before making that transition?
Anderson Williams: One, clarity for what it means to manage people and, and, and what it means to, for their– help them see and understand what their day-to-day work, uh, is gonna look like and how it’s different than what it has been.
Um, they need to understand the challenges, especially if they are pr- being promoted to a manager, uh, over people who were formerly colleagues and peers. Uh, and to be honest about those challenges and the power dynamics that can arise. Uh, I just think it’s an honest conversation, um, because the, the, the, the thing that we end up doing is, is taking people who are really good and really key players in our teams out of the roles that they’re happiest, most successful, most valuable to us, and put them into roles they don’t understand, they didn’t really want, and then we lose them.
Uh, and it’s because we just didn’t go in eyes wide open, and they didn’t go in eyes wide open to this opportunity.
Jackson Sprayberry: It’s really helpful. I think that’s a good primer and a good place to end this episode for the remainder of the season. And, you know, the promotion itself is the event, but then the transition into that new role is really the hardest work, arguably the hardest work.
How does somebody moving into that manager role let go of the work that they perhaps the best on their team at, and what does that look like day to day? And we’re gonna talk about that in the next episode.
Anderson Williams: Sounds good.
Listen and subscribe to Raw Talent on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts, and find every Shore University show, including Bigger. Stronger. Faster., Microcap Moments, and Everyday Heroes, at shorecp.university/podcasts.